Sunday, November 29, 2009

Too. Many. Men.

One play. One mistake. That's all it came down to in one of the craziest endings to a football game I've ever seen. After Saskatchewan got stopped deep in their own end and punted, they still seemed to have a great chance to hang on and win. In fact, disaster almost struck for Montreal on the punt itself when Brian Bratton bobbled and then fumbled it, but Etienne Boulay saved the day, diving on the ball. Still, Montreal only had 40 seconds to work with, no timeouts and a starting position on their own 34. There were a few mishaps, but Anthony Calvillo completed two long passes and Montreal was in position to kick the winning field goal, but it was from long range and kicker Damon Duval had struggled all game. The ball was snapped, the hold was good, but Duval drove it well right of the uprights. Jason Armstead ran it out and took a knee, and it looked like the Riders had won.

Not so fast. In a moment reminiscent of the legendary call that ended Don Cherry's coaching career with the Bruins, a flag flew. Saskatchewan was called for too many men on the field, the ball was moved 10 yards closer, and Duval got another chance. He made no mistake this time,giving Montreal a 28-27 victory.

This fits right in with the column I wrote earlier this year about the overemphasis we frequently place on quarterbacks. Both Calvillo and Darian Durant had reasonably good days after slow starts, but neither was the decisive factor. If Boulay hadn't had the presence of mind to dive on that fumble, Calvillo wouldn't have even had a chance to lead that final drive, and if Saskatchewan hadn't had too many men on the field, the drive wouldn't have mattered.

Still, you can bet there will be plenty of stories about Calvillo's veteran leadership, even though he wasn't on the field for the sole play that turned a loss into a win. In fact, the Alouettes didn't even really win, as the best efforts of their players resulted in a loss. It was Saskatchewan's critical error that made the difference. That doesn't mean the rest of the game gets ignored, but it needs to be kept in perspective. The Alouettes played a great game and made a great comeback, but it was a penalty that turned a loss into a win.


  1. Good stuff ... Durant did have two second-half interceptions, let's not forget.

    There is saying the ball will always bounce for the team with the better quarterback.

    How about the 'Riders kicking the field goal instead of trying for a TD from the 2-yard line at the end of the first half? Score there and it's 21-3.

  2. Good points, Neate. Quarterbacks are still the most important position, but Durant made lots of plays down the stretch too; I don't think QB play was really the difference. I didn't like the call to kick the FG. There were plenty of other points that could have swung it too, including Saskatchewan declining that penalty and allowing a single; without that a FG only ties it. Still, the too-many-men penalty cost the Riders the game regardless of whatever else happened.

  3. This week's "sharp wisdom from someone who doesn't know football" goes to a friend of mine, who asked, in regards to the Als' last-minute drive:

    "If you can move down the field that quickly with 28 seconds left, why don't you do those plays earlier in the game?"

    We did not have an answer for her.

  4. Sometimes, Rob. There really isn't an answer. And yes, Andrew, I agree with your statement. It was the Roughriders' game to lose, and lose they did...

    As the saying goes, "Penalties kill."

  5. Anonymous8:08 AM

    This is a great tip particularly to those fresh to the
    blogosphere. Short but very precise info… Thank you for
    sharing this one. A must read article!

    My site; twitter buy followers

  6. Anonymous2:51 PM

    Greetings! Very helpful advice within this article!
    It is the little changes that make the most important changes.
    Many thanks for sharing!

    Feel free to visit my blog ... kitchen in northern virginia

  7. Anonymous11:22 PM

    Heya! I'm at work browsing your blog from my new iphone 3gs! Just wanted to say I love reading your blog and look forward to all your posts! Keep up the fantastic work!

    Here is my web page: baby boomer market